Posts tonen met het label Military intervention. Alle posts tonen
Posts tonen met het label Military intervention. Alle posts tonen

oktober 30, 2011

Catching Kony: altruism or geopolitics?

Some days ago I learned that president Obama is going to send military reinforcements to Uganda. This is announced in a time when the US military presence in Iraq is almost completely reduced. The goal of the military venture is to make an end to the activities of Joseph Kony and his Lord's Resistance Army (LRA). The LRA is a renegade rebel army that seeks to overthrow the Ugandan government. It is hard to convey an image of the LRA in brief, but I'll try it nonetheless: it combines a mix(ed)-up ideology rooted in Christianity, traditional African mysticism and Acholi nationalism. The LRA recruits children in its ranks by raiding villages, accompanied by the many cruelties commonly associate with child soldiers (think rape, murder and drugs).

Entire Mid-Eastern Africa is politically troubled:
(1) Somalia as a 'failed state' and the many refugees in Kenya
(2) South Sudan, only just independent, is extremely poor
(3) The Great Lakes with the LRA and refugee camps in Goma
(4) The unstable Central African Republic with lots of violence
Would it be wise to add more military to the equation?
You can imagine how relieved I was to learn that the United States would 'finally' do something worthwhile with its military capacity. An emotional reaction and, as it turned out, a biased one. Without any doubt a monster like Kony has to be stopped. But several aspects have been left out of the picture when Uncle Sam presented its great humanitarian deed to the world. First of all, LRA activities in the region have been on a low pitch since 2007. The rebellion against the government is not what it once was and this might open the way for non-military conflict resolution. It is however the corrupted Ugandan regime that seems to put on its brake when being asked for more democracy, pluralism and liberties.

A second noteworthy fact is that the United States are already involved in hunting down Kony and other LRA leaders. So far their tactics didn't prove very successful. It is very doubtful that stronger military pressure would be a road to result. Some would even dare to say that it might undermine regional stability even further, actually endangering the common people more than was the case since 2007. But American-Ugandan ties have strengthened during the War on Terror in Somalia. Another major strategic importance of good ties with the Ugandan authorities are the oil reserves in the nearby region. Especially now that South Sudan, with considerable reserves, became independent.

What first seemed an altruist deed to protect people now looks a lot grimmer. And it is easy to buy the 'peacekeeper' story, even when being sold by a country that has a pretty nasty record of military interventions. The reason that we are tempted to do so is that we are under-informed on the Ugandan situation, and African politics in general. The lesson I learned: stay informed or stay sceptic.

september 28, 2011

Youthful idealism

Today, I had my first class of the new academic term. The course in question was Theory of International Relations and the lesson provided me with some - much needed - inspiration for this blog. People who read my first contribution to Blogger might start to see a pattern. ;-)

Anyhow, the first lesson wasn't the average introduction speech on which text book to use etc. Quite the contrary; the prof used his premiere to test our worth. We were asked to engage in a hundred person debate revolving around one given question: Why did the NATO intervene in Libya? As the exemplary students we are, many a valuable contribution was made. We stressed the importance of regional stability, the perceived threat of political Islam and of course the inescapable Libyan oil reserves. One explanation was remarkably absent from the debate, accidentally the official one. Can you by any chance remember French head of state Nicolas Sarkozy mentioning the violation of human rights by the Libyan regime? Or maybe you recall American president Obama saying something about the protection of Libyan citizens?

For some reason my fellow students didn't buy the noble motives NATO itself put forth. Is it naive to rejoice when I hear Belgian military planes will help to enforce the no-fly zone? Sure, the NATO members have their agenda, but a nationwide massacre was avoided. It came as a genuine shock to me how harsh and negative the people I socialize with sounded. My grandma portrays more joie de vivre than our entire theatre together and she's almost eighty! It is good to have a critical attitude, but most comments left a real bitter taste. Luckily the professor assumed the role of devil's advocate and pointed out the multitude of facets involved. He kept cool and made clear we are hypocrites out of necessity: we don't protect the Chechens because Russia has nuclear arms, we don't support the Syrian uprising since Assad has close ties with Iran, etc. Just like him, I believe that the political elite of the democratic west wants to address those issues. The price is however too high to pay and so we abstain.

The lesson I learned today is that idealism on it itself doesn't do much good, even though I often flirt with it myself. To all readers who just like me enjoy the occasional stay at Castle Sky: dreaming of a better world is a must, but reality is a bitch. Even idealists should take it into account if they seek a resolution. The blinding light of prefabricated ideologies - of whichever kind - can muddle our vision when dealing with REAL problems. Situations are often more complex than we tend to present them, so remember: it's all swings and roundabouts! :p